Skip to content
Bruce Friedman MediationBruce Friedman Mediation
Bruce Friedman Mediation
Mediation and Arbitration in Los Angeles
  • Home
  • About
    • Litigation Experience
    • Mediation & Arbitration Case Summaries
  • Services
    • Arbitration Services
    • Mediation Services
  • Testimonials
  • News & Blog
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About
    • Litigation Experience
    • Mediation & Arbitration Case Summaries
  • Services
    • Arbitration Services
    • Mediation Services
  • Testimonials
  • News & Blog
  • Contact

As Featured on Law360: Shepherding Insurers Through The Mediation Process

Oct92015
Publications

In a recent Law360 article, mediator Bruce Friedman discusses ‘Shepherding Insurers Through The Mediation Process’.

While insurance lawsuits involving claims directly between an insurance company and its policyholder make up a relatively small percentage of our courts dockets, cases triggering liability insurance from automobile accidents to securities class actions constitute a very large percentage of all cases before our courts. Settlement of these cases requires the proper shepherding of the insurer(s) defending/covering the case. The participation of the insurer(s) at the mediation is necessary to the ultimate resolution of the case. The challenge is making sure that the insurer(s) are prepared to participate in the mediation in a meaningful way.

What does it take to make sure that all insurers are present and prepared to settle the case? First and foremost, the insurer must be on notice of the lawsuit and be provided with reasonable notice of any settlement mediation. This is not only a predicate to the participation of the insurer in the settlement of the case, but may also be a requirement of the insurance policy. Second, a representative of the insurer needs to be at the mediation. If the case has a large verdict potential, then all primary and excess insures should be present at the mediation. If the case can be settled within the policy limits of the primary insurer, then it may be necessary for the plaintiff to have made a policy limits demand prior to the mediation in order for the case to be settled. A policy limits demand is a demand by the plaintiff for the limits of the policy in full settlement of the case. The demand may have the effect of opening up the policy limits of a policy exposing the insurer to payment of a judgment in excess of the policy limits in the event that the case is not settled within the limits.

Large exposure cases against institutional defendants whether they are serious injury, death or class actions, require that all insurers, primary and excess, participate in the mediation of the case. Obviously, the presence of the excess insurer is necessary if the settlement is going to exceed the primary limit. Less obvious, but very important, is the legal dynamic between the primary and excess insurers. The primary insurer has a duty to the excess insurer to settle the case within its limits if it can do so. The excess insurer is going to assert pressure on the primary insurer to resolve the case within its limits and in essence is an ally of the plaintiff in this regard. Multiple layers of excess insurance present the same dynamic as the settlement amount goes up the tower of insurance. Absent the participation of the excess insurer(s), large exposure cases cannot be settled.

Then there are those liability cases that present insurance coverage issues. Those issues include whether there is coverage, whether an exclusion applies, whether a policy condition has been breached and others. Under these circumstances, it is necessary for all parties to be aware of the coverage issue going into the mediation in order to understand and analyze whether and to what extent the issue will have on the insurer’s willingness to settle the case. The insurer may have retained coverage counsel to advise it on the issue who may be in attendance at the mediation. The plaintiff or policyholder may also want to consider hiring coverage counsel to provide advice on the issue and to attend the mediation. The insurer will undoubtedly assert that the coverage issue must be considered in terms of how much it will contribute to settlement of the case. The insurer will argue that it should pay less than it would have paid if the issue did not exist. In cases where the defendant/policyholder does not have the ability to pay a judgment or simply will not settle with its own funds, the coverage issue may present a serious impediment to settlement. Understanding the merits of the issue is necessary to effectively address it and reach a resolution of the third party suit.

Whether you represent the plaintiff or the defendant/policyholder, discovery and understanding the liability insurance applicable to your case is a very important aspect of any lawsuit and necessary to an effective resolution of the case. A case should not proceed to mediation unless and until the participation of the insurer(s) is secured. Many mediations are stopped short of settlement because of the lack of effective participation of insurers. That participation is the responsibility of all of the interested parties to the case, plaintiff, defendant and insurer.

To read the full article on Law360, click here.

To learn more about Bruce’s practice, click here.

Category: PublicationsBy bfriedmanOctober 9, 2015
Tags: Benefits of Mediationmediationmediation tipsmediator

Author: bfriedman

Post navigation

PreviousPrevious post:Bruce Friedman Discusses the Early Mediation of Insurance Coverage Cases on Law.comNextNext post:Featured on Law.com: Impasse-Busting Techniques – Part 2

Related posts

Bruce Friedman Discusses the Early Mediation of Insurance Coverage Cases on Law.com
March 24, 2016
Featured on Law.com: Impasse-Busting Techniques – Part 2
September 10, 2015
Mediation of Insurance Coverage Cases
August 5, 2014
The Ethical Neutral: What Must Be Disclosed In Mediation (via Law360)
May 31, 2013
Blog Categories
  • Benefits of Mediation(2)
  • Bruce's Corner(30)
  • Honors(1)
  • Mediation(39)
  • Publications(5)
Recent Posts
  • Bruce Friedman Discusses the Early Mediation of Insurance Coverage Cases on Law.com
    March 24, 2016
  • As Featured on Law360: Shepherding Insurers Through The Mediation Process
    October 9, 2015
  • Featured on Law.com: Impasse-Busting Techniques – Part 2
    September 10, 2015
  • As Featured on Law.com: Effective Impasse Busting Techniques
    May 8, 2015
Testimonials
  • [Bruce] knows when to talk, when to listen, and how to work the room.”

    James Thompson
    JPT Legal
  • Bruce took time to point out parts of each side’s case that could be made stronger and parts that could be deemphasized or omitted. Bottom line: the client came out of the exercise with a more focused case and better able to advance its positions. Bruce was superb.

    Ellis Mirsky
    The Network of Trial Lawyers
  • Bruce was prepared and understood the issues and the practical aspects of the cases. I really appreciated Bruce’s efforts in continuing to work with me and opposing counsel and his perseverance in settling the case.

    Frederick S. Reisz
    Meyers McConnell
  • I have known Bruce for years and highly recommend him. As a native New Yorker, he will be hearing significant matters in NYC as well as in L.A.

    Jeffrey Kravtiz
    Fox Rothschild
  • Bruce’s willingness to continue to follow up with both sides to settle the matter and his efforts in speaking directly with the clients to explain the issues and possible outcomes should the case proceed to trial were invaluable.

    P. Garrell
    Liner Law Firm
  • From the outset of the mediation, it was clear that Bruce understood the case and structure of a class action settlement. He was effective in his discussion of the issues in the case and made many helpful and constructive suggestions with respect to the negotiating process and the settlement terms.

    Tim Blood
    Blood, Hurst & O'Reardon LLP
Resources
linked in for bruce friedman attorney los angeles mediation services
Los Angeles Office

555 West Fifth Street
(Gas Company Tower)
32nd Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90013
T: (800) 352-JAMS

View Map & Directions

Century City Office

JAMS Services
The Watt Plaza
1925 Century Park E
Los Angeles, CA  90067 
310-392-3044

View Map & Directions

 

©2018 Bruce A. Friedman. All Rights Reserved
  • Home
  • Privacy Policy / Terms of Use
  • Contact
  • Web Design by WebPresenceesq.com
Privacy